US President Trump threatened on July 14th that if a Russia-Ukraine peace agreement didn’t happen within 50 days, then very high secondary tariffs would be imposed on Russia’s trading partners. As explained below, this is an empty threat.
China is Russia’s most important trading partner, so this is a threat to again impose extremely high tariffs on US imports from China. Now, the probability of a Russia-Ukraine peace agreement within the next 50 days is low and the probability that China will stop trading with Russia in response to this threat is zero, so the likely outcome 50 days from now is that Trump will be forced to either carry out his threat or back down. If he doesn’t back down and makes good on his threat, we know what will happen because we watched the same scenario play out within the past few months.
The unilateral imposition of higher tariffs on Chinese imports to the US would cause China’s government to stop exporting Rare Earth Elements (REEs) and other critical metals to the US. Within a couple of months this would bring the US auto industry as well as US-based production of batteries, turbines, a lot of military equipment and anything that uses an electric motor to a virtual standstill, prompting the US government to strike a deal that substantially reduced the tariffs.
It turns out that the ultimate weapon in the ‘trade war’ is the Chinese government’s control of global REE supply, because the economic impact of stopping exports of these minerals is low for China and extremely high for the US and many other developed nations. This was proved over the past few months and will be proved again if the US government imposes hefty additional tariffs on China after 50 days.
Moreover, due to growing demand associated with high-tech applications, the extent to which REEs are critical will increase as time goes by. This is why we have had a strong focus on REEs over the past five years and why we expect REE mines and processing facilities outside China to become far more valuable over the years ahead.
One of the unintended consequences of Trump’s trade war has been to highlight the risk presented by the Chinese government’s influence on REE supply. This prompted the stock market to start pricing-in the increasingly urgent need to diversify in this area, which has involved some rapid valuation changes. For example, the stock prices of Energy Fuels (TSX:) (UUUU) and Neo Performance Materials (NEO.TO), two of the TSI stock selections that provide exposure to REEs, have more than doubled from their lows of the past four months.
A chart of Energy Fuels (NYSE:) is included below. The recent frenetic price action suggests that we are nearing the end of the first leg of a cyclical bull market.
However, there haven’t yet been large increases in the prices of the underlying commodities.
Regarding the prices of the underlying commodities, the following chart shows the performance of Neodymium (Nd), one of the most widely used REEs. The chart reveals that although there has been a steady upward trend in the Nd price since March of 2024, the price remains very low relative to where it traded during the bulk of 2021-2023. Nd is a “light” REE and is not one of the REEs over which China’s government has a stranglehold on supply (heavy REEs such as Dysprosium (Dy) and Terbium (Tb) are more vulnerable to Chinese export restrictions), but as far as we can tell its price performance is representative.
The risk that the stock market has gone part of the way towards discounting is that REE prices are about to accelerate upward as the users of these metals around the world scramble to secure supply. In other words, the risk is that for REE prices we are at the equivalent of mid-2020.
