A recycling site in Cornwall, England, has been caught trashing the planet — and it shows why we need to put a red light on fake green claims fast.
According to the Environment Agency, officials discovered that Jake Bell, owner of S&J Recycling, had been illegally dumping and burning waste he had collected from paying customers who believed their waste was being disposed of properly.
During a site inspection, officials found piles of rubbish, including furniture, appliances, and more than 100 mattresses. Moreover, they found that the site didn’t have proper permits. Bell said he was a licensed waste carrier and intended to dispose of the waste legally, but admitted he had “no idea” about required permits.
After repeated warnings, investigators discovered he had shifted operations to another site, where they again found mixed waste and signs of illegal burning. Bell was charged and handed a suspended prison sentence, along with 120 hours of unpaid work, £480 ($651) in costs, and a nightly curfew for four months.
Bell’s vague description of how he operates his recycling business has been cited as an example of greenwashing. When companies mislead people about environmental practices, trust erodes — affecting legitimate businesses with genuinely sustainable practices.
Because of greenwashing, approximately half of consumers worldwide report distrust in environmental claims, according to Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development data. This loss of confidence can slow the shift to sustainability.
Unfortunately, illegal and negligent environmental practices remain common. In one high-profile case, the head of Indonesia’s land agency was found guilty of accepting bribes from palm oil companies, a practice that fueled deforestation. In Florida, a resort owner was fined after cutting down protected mangroves without authorization.
On the bright side, some initiatives help curtail greenwashing, such as stronger policies like California’s heat-trapping pollution reporting law. Other promising solutions include the European Union’s proposed Green Claims Directive, which would require companies to provide scientific proof of environmental claims.
Green-sounding labels don’t always equal clean practices — which is why everyone needs to know how to spot greenwashing. Individuals can help raise awareness as they talk about climate issues and push for change at work and at home.
As for business owners like Bell, it would behoove them to heed this warning from the Environment Agency said: “Our dedicated Area Enforcement Team won’t hesitate to go after such illegal activity.”
Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don’t miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.